(631) 825-8747
Get Your Offer

Capital Gains Tax When You Sell a House in New York, Explained by a CPA

Avatar photo Mike Plactere, CPA on September 1, 2026

If the house was your primary residence, you can often keep most or all of your profit tax free. Under federal law (IRC §121) you can exclude up to $250,000 of gain if you file single, or $500,000 married filing jointly, as long as you owned and lived in the home as your main home for at least 2 of the last 5 years. New York has no separate capital gains rate: whatever gain is left after that federal exclusion gets taxed as ordinary income (Tax Law §601). If you live in Nassau County or Suffolk County, you pay federal and New York State tax only, with no New York City income tax on the sale.

I am Mike Plactere. I buy houses directly across Long Island, and I am also a licensed CPA, so I spend a lot of time on the number that actually matters to a seller: what you walk away with after the sale is done. This post is general education, not advice on your specific return. Your own gain depends on your basis and your situation, so run your real numbers with your own CPA. But here is how the pieces fit together so you are not scared off by the wrong rate.

One Google reviewer, Paul, put it this way: "Mike is able to explain in layman terms where the real estate market has been and where it['s] heading. His real estate tax knowledge as a CPA has helped my retirement strategy..." That is the lens I am writing from here.

White colonial house with black shutters on a Long Island street at dusk, the kind of home sale where capital gains tax questions start

The three tax rates you keep hearing, and which ones are real

Search "capital gains tax New York" and you will run into three different numbers, usually at the same time:

  • 15% (a federal long-term capital gains bracket).
  • 10.90% (the top New York State income tax rate).
  • 1% (the "mansion tax").

Here is the problem. Those three numbers measure three different things, and for a Massapequa or Levittown homeowner selling a primary residence, none of them may be your actual bill. The 15% is federal only. The 10.90% is a top New York rate that applies to very high incomes, not to most home sales. The 1% mansion tax is not a capital gains tax at all: it is a tax on the sale price, and it usually falls on the buyer, not you.

So separate two systems in your head before you do anything else.

Two separate tax systems: profit vs price

When you sell, two completely different kinds of tax can show up, and mixing them is where sellers get scared for no reason.

1. Income tax on your profit (the gain). This is federal capital gains tax plus New York State income tax on whatever gain you cannot exclude. This is where IRC §121 does its work.

2. Transfer taxes on the sale price. These are the state transfer tax, the 1% mansion tax on sales of $1,000,000 or more, and, on the East End, the Peconic Bay Community Preservation Fund. These are charged on the price of the deal, not your profit, and they are not capital gains.

Keep those two buckets apart and the whole subject gets a lot calmer.

Federal capital gains and the IRC §121 home-sale exclusion

For most people selling the home they actually live in, this is the section that matters.

Shingled Long Island cottage with a front porch and garden, a primary residence that can qualify for the federal home sale exclusion

How the gain is figured

Your gain is not your sale price. It is your sale price minus selling expenses, minus your adjusted basis (IRS Topic 409). Basis starts with what you paid, then goes up for capital improvements and certain costs, and can be adjusted for things like depreciation you claimed (IRS Pub 551; IRS Pub 523). A house held more than a year is long-term (IRS Topic 409). Rebuilding basis correctly (every improvement, every receipt) is exactly the kind of homework you do with your CPA, because it directly lowers your gain.

The exclusion

If, during the 5-year period ending on the sale date, you owned and used the property as your principal residence for periods adding up to 2 years or more, you can exclude up to $250,000 of gain (single) or $500,000 (married filing jointly) (IRC §121; IRS Topic 701). A few rules to know:

  • Once every two years. You cannot use the exclusion if you already excluded gain on another home sale within the 2 years ending on this sale date (IRC §121(b)(3)).
  • Depreciation is not excluded. Gain tied to depreciation you took after May 6, 1997 (for a home office or a rental period) does not get the exclusion (IRC §121(d)(6)).
  • A reduced exclusion exists. If you fall short of the 2-year test because of a job change, a health issue, or another unforeseen circumstance, you may still get a partial exclusion (IRC §121(c)).

Reporting

Even if your gain is fully excluded, you may still have to report the sale. If you receive a Form 1099-S at closing, or if any part of the gain is not fully excludable, you report it on Form 8949 and Schedule D (IRS Topic 701). "Under the cap so I never file" is not a safe assumption. Ask your CPA whether your closing generated a 1099-S.

If you still have taxable gain: federal rates

Say your gain is bigger than the exclusion, or the home does not qualify. The leftover gain is taxed at the federal long-term capital gains rates of 0%, 15%, or 20%, depending on your taxable income.

For the 2026 tax year, the brackets from Rev. Proc. 2025-32 are laid out in the official IRS document:

  • Single: 0% up to $49,450 of taxable income, 15% up to $545,500, 20% above that.
  • Married filing jointly: 0% up to $98,900, 15% up to $613,700, 20% above that.

These thresholds are inflation-adjusted and change every year, so confirm the current year's figures against the IRS before you rely on them.

There is also the Net Investment Income Tax, an extra 3.8% that can apply when your modified adjusted gross income is over $200,000 (single) or $250,000 (married filing jointly) (IRS Topic 559; IRS NIIT overview). One important point: gain you exclude under IRC §121 is not net investment income, so the excluded part of a primary-residence sale does not get hit with the 3.8% (IRS NIIT overview).

The New York twist: no special capital gains rate

New York does not have a separate, lower rate for capital gains. New York starts from your federal adjusted gross income (Tax Law §612), so gain you already excluded federally under §121 generally is not in your New York income either. Any recognized gain that remains gets taxed as ordinary income on New York's regular brackets (Tax Law §601).

For the 2026 tax year, New York's bracket structure under §601 runs from a bottom rate of 3.90% up to a top rate of 10.90% on very high income (Tax Law §601). That 10.90% is the top of a progressive scale, not a flat home-sale tax, and it applies to income far above what a typical Long Island home sale produces. As with the federal figures, these rates can change year to year, so re-verify against the statute for the year you sell.

So when a blog tells you "the New York capital gains rate is 15%," that is wrong. There is no New York capital gains rate. New York taxes the leftover gain as ordinary income, and 15% is a federal bracket.

Long Island residency: no New York City income tax

This one saves Long Island sellers real money and gets missed constantly.

New York City's personal income tax is a tax on New York City residents. If you live in Nassau County or Suffolk County, you are not a New York City resident, so you do not pay New York City income tax on your home sale gain. The same goes for New York City's extra progressive "mansion" tiers: those are New York City add-ons and do not apply to a house in Massapequa, Huntington Station, or anywhere else on Long Island.

Long Island homeowner selling a primary residence: your income tax picture is federal plus New York State only. Do not let a New York City calculator inflate your number.

Nonresidents and snowbirds: Form IT-2663 at closing

If you are not a New York resident (you moved to Florida, you are an out-of-state investor, or you retired somewhere warmer and changed your domicile), there is a closing mechanic you need to know about on Long Island.

New York requires nonresidents to estimate and pre-pay New York income tax on the gain from selling New York real property, using Form IT-2663, at the highest §601 rate for the year, which is 10.90% for 2026 (Tax Law §663; Form IT-2663 (2026)). This is a recording gate: the county recording officer will not record the deed without the estimated-tax payment, the receipt showing it was paid, or a certification that the section does not apply (Tax Law §663(d)). On Long Island this is real: the Suffolk County Clerk lists IT-2663 among the forms required to record a deed (Suffolk County Clerk recording forms).

Two things people get wrong here:

  • It is a tax on the gain, not the whole sale price. IT-2663 estimates tax on your gain, not 10.90% of everything you sold the house for (Tax Law §663).
  • A principal residence can be exempt. If the property is your principal residence within the meaning of IRC §121, the section provides an exception, so the IT-2663 payment may not be required (Tax Law §663(c)). Your closing attorney and CPA handle the certification. This is worth flagging early, because it is a closing-critical item for a nonresident seller. It lands at the very end of the sale timeline, which we map out step by step in how long it takes to sell a house in New York.

Closing-cost taxes that are not capital gains

These are charged on the price of the deal, not your profit. They can hit at closing whether or not you have any taxable gain at all.

House keys with a house-shaped keychain, a folder, and a pen on a kitchen counter, ready for a New York home closing
  • New York State real estate transfer tax (RETT). The base rate is $2 for each $500 of consideration (or a fraction of it) when the price is over $500, which works out to about 0.4% of the price. It is generally paid by the seller (Tax Law §1402; N.Y. Dept. of Taxation and Finance).
  • The "mansion tax." This is an additional 1% on residential property when the consideration is $1,000,000 or more, and it is generally paid by the buyer, not the seller (Tax Law §1402-a; N.Y. Dept. of Taxation and Finance). It is a transfer tax on the price. It is not capital gains, and it is not your profit being taxed.
  • The Peconic Bay Community Preservation Fund (CPF). On the five East End towns of Suffolk County (East Hampton, Riverhead, Shelter Island, Southampton, and Southold), there is a local real estate transfer tax that funds land preservation. It is a transfer tax, not a capital gains tax. In the Town of Southampton, the rate is 2.5% (which includes a 0.5% Community Housing Fund portion), with an exemption on the first $100,000 of vacant land or the first $400,000 of improved residential property when the consideration is $2,000,000 or less (Town of Southampton CPF FAQ). The exact CPF rate is set town by town, so if your house is in East Hampton, Riverhead, Shelter Island, or Southold, confirm that town's current rate with the town and your closing attorney before you count on a number.

Most of Long Island (Nassau County and the rest of Suffolk County) is not in the Peconic CPF towns, so for a typical Massapequa or Levittown sale the CPF is not part of the picture.

Do your basis homework

The single biggest lever a seller controls is basis, because gain is sale price minus basis. Capital improvements over the years, certain closing costs, and other adjustments raise your basis and lower your gain (IRS Pub 551; IRS Pub 523). If you inherited the home, took depreciation, or ran a home office, the math changes. Pull your records together and let your CPA reconstruct your real basis. This is not a place to guess.

FAQ

Does selling to a cash buyer change my capital gains tax?

No. Selling for cash or selling "as-is" does not create any capital gains exemption. The rules in IRC §121, New York's §601, and the nonresident §663 mechanic do not care whether the buyer paid cash or got a mortgage (IRC §121; Tax Law §601). A cash sale can change your price and your timeline. It does not change the tax rules. Anyone who tells you cash is a tax holiday is wrong.

I inherited a house. How is my gain figured?

When you inherit property, your basis is generally the fair market value at the date of death, not what the person who left it to you originally paid (IRC §1014; IRS Pub 551). This "stepped-up basis" often shrinks the gain a lot, because you only pay on appreciation since you inherited it. Estate-tax consistency rules can apply, so have your CPA confirm the date-of-death value and your basis. We break down the full inherited-house tax picture, Long Island specifics included, in our guide to taxes when selling an inherited house on Long Island.

It was a rental. What about depreciation?

The §121 exclusion does not automatically apply to a rental or investment property. It applies to a home you owned and used as your principal residence for at least 2 of the last 5 years, so a pure rental usually does not qualify unless you converted it and met the tests (IRC §121). On top of that, gain tied to depreciation you took (or could have taken) after May 6, 1997 is not excludable and gets its own treatment (IRC §121(d)(6)). Depreciation recapture is exactly the kind of item a CPA should run for you before closing.

We are selling because of a divorce. Does that change things?

It can. Transfers of property between spouses or former spouses incident to a divorce are often nonrecognition events, and §121 has special rules that can let a spouse count the other spouse's ownership or use in some cases (IRC §1041; IRS Pub 523). Divorce sales get fact-specific fast, so this is a your-CPA-and-your-attorney conversation.

I have owned it less than 2 years. Am I stuck paying full tax?

Not necessarily. If you are selling before you hit the 2-year mark because of a change in your place of employment, a health issue, or an unforeseen circumstance, you may qualify for a reduced (prorated) exclusion instead of losing it entirely (IRC §121(c)). The rules define what counts, so have your CPA check whether your reason qualifies.

A plain disclaimer

This post is general information, not tax or legal advice, and it does not cover every situation. All rates and thresholds above are for the 2026 tax year, and they change every year: federal brackets are inflation-adjusted annually, and New York's rates and forms are updated too. Before you rely on anything here, run your own numbers with a CPA, confirm the details with a closing attorney, and check the current figures against the primary sources listed below for the year you actually sell.

Sources

Selling a Long Island house for cash, without the guesswork

Well-kept Long Island split-level house with a two-car garage on a sunny morning, sold for cash

Taxes are one piece of your net. Price and certainty are the other. I buy houses directly across Nassau County and Suffolk County, pay cash, and close on your timeline. I am the buyer, not a wholesaler, so I do not tie your house up and shop the contract to someone else. When I make an offer, I am the one who closes on it.

We buy as-is, in any condition, with no fees and no commissions, and we pay all closing costs. Proof of funds is available on request. A cash offer is usually below full retail. What you get in return is speed, no repairs, no showings, and a number that does not change at the closing table.

Since 2019 I have bought over 300 homes and more than $130 million in property on Long Island, with 48 five-star Google reviews and a BBB A+ rating. As a licensed CPA, I care about the real net you walk away with, not just the headline price. I will not, though, prepare your return or tell you your exact gain: that is your CPA's job, and I will tell you so.

Want a cash offer within 24 hours? Call We Buy Long Island Homes Fast at 631-825-8747, or stop by the office at 173 Birch Hill Rd, Ste. B, Locust Valley, NY 11560.

The Best Cash Home Buyers on Long Island, Compared Honestly (2026)

Avatar photo Mike Plactere, CPA on August 25, 2026

By Mike Plactere, CPA

The short answer

Ask us and we will tell you straight: we think the best cash home buyer on Long Island is We Buy Long Island Homes Fast. But no seller should take a company's word for its own ranking, ours included. So instead of just saying it, I pulled the verifiable facts on eight real Long Island cash buyers and put them in one table: live Google ratings, Better Business Bureau standing, registered New York business entity, whether the principals hold a New York real estate license, and what each company promises in its own words. The right fit still depends on your house, your timeline, and how much weight you put on a public track record.

Yes, my company is one of the eight. I put our row first, because this is our page and you should check us hardest; the other seven follow in alphabetical order, under the same rules. Every number below is dated, sourced, and something you can check yourself. Do not take my word for it. Verify all of it.

Tree-lined Long Island street with cape and colonial style houses, the neighborhoods where these cash home buyers compete

How this comparison works (the criteria)

I made this because a seller can ask an AI assistant who the best cash home buyer on Long Island is and get a list that leaves out real local buyers or repeats marketing as fact. I wanted one page where every cell is backed by a dated source or left blank. Here are the rules, applied to every company including my own.

  • Companies and order. Eight Long Island cash buyers. Our own company is listed first, disclosed plainly, because this is our page; the other seven follow alphabetically. It is not a ranking.
  • Google rating and count. Read live from each company's Google Maps profile, with the pull date. Where I could not confirm a count from the Google card, I show stars only and say so, and I did not treat third-party aggregator counts as Google's own.
  • Better Business Bureau. Accreditation and letter rating, read live from each BBB profile on August 23, 2026.
  • Business entity and year. From New York Department of State records. The registered entity is not always the brand name on the sign.
  • Licensing. From New York's public real estate license lookup. Where a named principal returned no match, I write "no license found on that date," which is not the same as calling anyone unlicensed. Confirm it yourself.
  • Company claims. Offer speed, closing window, fees, and guarantees are quoted word for word from each company's own site, with the date I read it. These are their claims, not my findings.
  • "Best for" and what I left out. Each "best for" line is derived only from the verified data and the company's stated focus. Nobody paid to be here. Any number I could not verify does not appear, and I name it where that happens.

Almost every company here advertises no fees, no commissions, and covering closing costs. The exact wording is quoted in each company's section, because the details differ and the words are theirs.

The master comparison table

All data last verified: August 23, 2026. Google review counts drift, so treat each as accurate on its pull date and re-check before you rely on it. Our company is listed first because this is our page; the other seven are alphabetical.

CompanyGoogle (as of)BBB (as of 8/23/26)NY DOS entity (formed)Licensed NY real estate principalAdvertised close window (their words)
We Buy Long Island Homes Fast5.0, 48 reviews (as of 8/22/26, corroborated 8/23/26)Accredited, A+ (since 6/28/24)Principal Equity Holdings LLC (2020, Nassau)Michael Plactere, salesperson #10401372444 (Current, exp 12/20/26); also NY CPA #120535"close on your timeline"
Elite Properties NY4.0, 6 reviews (8/23/26)No BBB profile foundElite Properties Nyc Team LLC (2019, Kings)No RE license found for named principals (8/22/26)"in just 3 days"
Gem Hunter Property Solutions5.0, 12 reviews (8/23/26)Accredited, A+ (since 5/23/23)Gem Hunter Property Solutions LLC, foreign NV, NY authority 2020 (Suffolk)No RE license found for Nicole Cooper (8/22/26)"few days to a few weeks"
Handsome Homebuyer4.5 stars; count not confirmed (8/23/26)Not accredited, A+Handsome Homebuyer LLC (2022, Nassau)No RE license found for owner Charles Weinraub; Jay Weinraub holds corp broker #10311209439 tied to Handsome Real Estate Incclose "in a week or in a year"
House Buyers LINo Google profile found (8/22 to 8/23/26)No BBB profile foundHouse Buyers Li LLC (2022, Albany registration)Principal surnames not public; individual license search not completed"As soon as 7 days, or longer if desired"
Leave The Key Homebuyers5.0, 69 reviews (8/23/26)Accredited, A+ (since 11/21/23)Mid-island Property Solutions LLC (2019, Suffolk), DBA Leave The Key HomebuyersNo confirmed RE license for named principals (8/22/26); see note in their section"as little as 7 days or as long as a few months"
Prestige Home Buyers4.9, 34 reviews (8/23/26)Accredited, A+ (since 4/6/20)Prestige Home Buyers Inc (2019, Suffolk)Warner Quiroga, salesperson #10401314361 (Current)"in as little as seven days"
Suffolk County House Buyers4.9, 60 reviews (as of 8/22/26)Not accredited, ANY DOS entity not located in this searchNo RE license found for Jeremiah Dalton (8/22/26)"in as little as 3 weeks"

Company by company

Each section stands on its own: verified facts with dates, the company's own claims in its own words, and one data-derived line on fit.

We Buy Long Island Homes Fast

This is my company, listed first because the page is ours, so hold it to the hardest standard.

Verified. Google 5.0, 48 reviews (Maps, 173 Birch Hill Rd, Ste. B, Locust Valley; as of August 22, 2026, corroborated August 23, 2026). BBB accredited, A+, since June 28, 2024. Entity Principal Equity Holdings LLC, NY DOS 5763623, filed June 8, 2020, active, Nassau County. I hold New York real estate salesperson license #10401372444, current, expiring December 20, 2026. I am also a licensed New York CPA, license #120535, verifiable in the NYSED Office of the Professions public lookup.

Our claims. "We buy houses across Nassau and Suffolk directly from homeowners, pay cash, and close on your timeline. No agents, no commissions, no wholesaling." "Guaranteed Cash Sale." "The offer we make is what you get." Our FAQ says "we can often close deals in as little as a week." We work Nassau and Suffolk, with Long Island as our primary focus.

Best for. Sellers who want a named, licensed principal (a New York real estate salesperson who is also a CPA) with an explicit no-wholesaling pledge and a focus on Long Island only.

Elite Properties NY

Verified. Google 4.0, 6 reviews (Maps, Brooklyn address, August 23, 2026). No BBB home-buyer profile found (August 22 to 23, 2026). Entity Elite Properties Nyc Team LLC, NY DOS 5466715, filed January 2, 2019, active, Kings County. No New York real estate license found for named principals Yehuda Zargarov, Saul Shauli, or Adam Shauli (August 22, 2026).

Their claims. "close the deal quickly, in just 3 days!" and "No Fees, No Commission." The site says they "primarily serves the five boroughs" plus Florida. I did not find Long Island named as a primary service area (August 23, 2026).

Best for. Sellers whose property is in the five NYC boroughs or Florida who want the fastest advertised close in this set (their claim of 3 days).

Gem Hunter Property Solutions

Verified. Google 5.0, 12 reviews (Maps, August 23, 2026). BBB accredited, A+, since May 23, 2023; Nicole Cooper CEO. Entity Gem Hunter Property Solutions, LLC (a Nevada company authorized in New York), NY DOS 5782022, New York authority July 7, 2020, active, Suffolk County. No New York real estate license found for Nicole Cooper (August 22, 2026).

Their claims. "The Gem Hunter Guarantee... No Agents! No Commissions! No Closing Costs!" and "Receive a no obligations offer within 24-48 hours!" The FAQ describes a "few days to a few weeks" process. Service area: Suffolk, Nassau, Queens, Brooklyn, and the Bronx.

Best for. Sellers who want a bundled no-commission, no-closing-cost package and are comfortable with a smaller published review count (12).

Handsome Homebuyer

Verified. Google star rating 4.5 (direct Maps card, August 23, 2026). I could not confirm the review count from the direct card, so I am not publishing one. BBB not accredited, A+; Charles Weinraub owner. Entity Handsome Homebuyer LLC, NY DOS 6399479, filed February 9, 2022, active, Nassau County (a related entity, Handsome Real Estate Inc, DOS 7561921, was filed March 18, 2025). No salesperson or broker license found for Charles Weinraub; a separate person, Jay Weinraub, holds corporate broker license #10311209439 tied to Handsome Real Estate Inc.

Their claims. "get a no-obligation offer in a day or less." On timing: "Whether you would like to close in a week or in a year we will schedule the closing on the day that works best for you." And: "In most cases we can advance our sellers money prior to closing." Service area: Suffolk and Nassau plus the five boroughs.

Best for. Sellers who want maximum flexibility on the closing date (their claim of a week to a year) and the option of an advance before closing.

House Buyers LI

Verified. No Google Business Profile found for this brand or domain (August 22 and 23, 2026; not to be confused with willbuysli.com or cashhomebuyersli.com). No BBB profile found. Entity House Buyers Li LLC, NY DOS 6536064, filed July 13, 2022, active, registered through an agent in Albany. The founders are named on the site only as "Jay and Noelle," with no public surnames, so an individual license search could not be completed.

Their claims. They "typically provide the offer within 15 minutes of the end of the walkthrough" and can close "As soon as 7 days, or longer if desired." On cost: "no repairs, fees, or closing costs – we cover them all." Service area: Nassau and Suffolk.

Best for. Sellers who want the fastest advertised offer in this set (their claim of 15 minutes after the walkthrough) and who are comfortable that no Google or BBB profile was found for the company as of August 23, 2026.

Leave The Key Homebuyers

Verified. Google 5.0, 69 reviews (Maps, Amityville address, August 23, 2026), the highest verified Google review count in this set. BBB accredited, A+, since November 21, 2023; Benjamin Wagner Partner. Entity Mid-island Property Solutions, LLC, NY DOS 5671776, filed December 13, 2019, active, Suffolk County, DBA Leave The Key Homebuyers. No license found for named principal Larry Wagner (August 22, 2026). A broker record exists under the name Benjamin Wagner, but I could not confirm it is the company's partner, so I am not claiming it as theirs.

Their claims. "We can close in as little as 7 days or as long as a few months if needed." "There are no fees, commissions..." They advertise a "Guaranteed closing" backed by a "10% non-refundable deposit," and say they are "Able to show cash proof of funds." Footprint: Long Island plus other parts of New York.

Best for. Sellers who want the largest verified Google review count in this set and deposit-backed closing language, across a footprint that reaches beyond Long Island.

Prestige Home Buyers

Verified. Google 4.9, 34 reviews (Maps, Brentwood address, August 23, 2026). BBB accredited, A+, since April 6, 2020, the longest BBB accreditation tenure in this set; Warner Quiroga President. Entity Prestige Home Buyers, Inc., NY DOS 5588506, filed July 17, 2019, active, Suffolk County. Warner Quiroga holds New York real estate salesperson license #10401314361, current.

Their claims. "Close on your timeline, or in as little as seven days!" "Our service is 100% free, meaning you will pay ZERO commission... We actually buy." On certainty: "If another company offers you more, we'll beat it," they "never back out of a transaction or try to re-negotiate," and "We always close on a transaction." They publish a pricing formula: "[Your Offer] = [After Repair Value] – [Repair Costs] – [Selling Costs] – [Our Minimum Profit]."

Best for. Sellers who want the strongest written close-certainty language in this set, the longest BBB accreditation tenure here, and a licensed owner.

Suffolk County House Buyers

Verified. Google 4.9, 60 reviews (Maps, August 22, 2026). BBB not accredited, A rating, three complaints noted; Jeremiah Dalton managing member. I could not locate this brand's exact New York DOS entity record in this search, so I am not publishing an entity name or ID. No license found for Jeremiah Dalton (August 22, 2026).

Their claims. "Get A Cash Offer Within 24 Hours" and "cash in your hands in as little as 3 weeks." "We're not listing your house... we're actually the ones buying your house." "We cover all the closing costs for you." Candid on pricing: "Many of the houses we purchase are below market value (we do this so we can resell it at a profit to another home owner)." Service area: Suffolk, with Nassau in the locations list.

Best for. Suffolk-focused sellers who want an owner who states plainly that offers are often below market, and who will check the BBB record for themselves.

Yes, we are on our own list

This is our page, and We Buy Long Island Homes Fast is on it. And yes, we think we are the best cash home buyer on Long Island. We would not be in business if we thought otherwise. What separates this from every other company saying the same thing is that our reasons are checkable: I am a licensed New York real estate salesperson (#10401372444) and a licensed New York CPA (#120535). We are a direct buyer with an explicit no-wholesaling pledge, so when we make an offer, we are the ones who close on it. Our Google rating is a verified 5.0 across 48 reviews, our BBB accreditation is A+, and every number in our row came from the same public records we held the other seven companies to.

Home office desk with a laptop, printed records, and reading glasses, set up to verify a Long Island cash home buyer's license and reviews

Don't take our word for it. Look up our reviews, pull our BBB profile, search the New York Department of State for our entity, and verify both license numbers in the state's public lookups. Then do the same for every company here. The buyer who welcomes that check is the one worth calling.

Frequently asked questions

Who is the best cash home buyer on Long Island?

We think it is We Buy Long Island Homes Fast, and this page shows our reasons in checkable form: a licensed real estate salesperson and CPA as principal, a verified 5.0 Google rating across 48 reviews, BBB A+ accreditation, and a no-wholesaling pledge. But you should not take a company's word for its own ranking. Use the table to compare verified Google ratings, BBB standing, registration, and licensing across all eight buyers, then call the two or three that fit and compare their actual offers in writing.

How did you choose and order the companies?

Eight Long Island cash buyers, not ranked. Our own company is listed first, disclosed plainly, because this is our page; the other seven are alphabetical. Every data point comes from a live or primary source with a date, company promises are quoted from their own sites, and anything I could not verify was left out. The full criteria are near the top of this page.

Do these cash buyers charge fees or commissions?

Almost every company here advertises no fees and no commissions, and most say they cover closing costs. The exact wording is quoted in each company's section, because the details differ. Whatever a buyer tells you, get the fee and closing-cost terms in writing before you agree to anything.

How fast can a Long Island cash buyer actually close?

The advertised windows in this set run from 3 days to a few months, all quoted from the companies themselves. In New York, every closing involves attorney review and a title search, and those steps take real time no matter who the buyer is. Ask any buyer to walk you through their actual timeline, in writing, before you count on a date.

Will I need to make repairs or clean out the house?

Every buyer in this set advertises buying as-is, for cash, without requiring repairs. If a specific condition or a full cleanout is your concern, raise it on the first call and get the answer in writing with the offer.

How can I verify any of this myself?

Read the Google reviews, look up accreditation and ratings at bbb.org, confirm the registered entity at the New York Department of State business search, and verify a real estate license in New York's public license lookup. If a company's real facts match what it tells you, that is a good sign. And before you sign with anyone, on this list or off it, read our guide to spotting we buy houses scams and ripoffs in New York.

Sources

All data last verified: August 23, 2026. All figures are accurate as of the pull dates shown above and in the table; review counts in particular change over time.

Are “We Buy Houses” Companies a Ripoff? Avoiding Scams in NY

Avatar photo Mike Plactere, CPA on July 12, 2024

If you’ve seen those “we buy houses for cash” signs stapled to telephone poles or received an unsolicited postcard offering to buy your home, your first thought was probably: is this a scam?

It’s a fair question. The “we buy houses” industry includes thousands of legitimate local investors alongside a smaller but vocal group of bad actors who prey on homeowners in vulnerable situations. In New York alone, the Attorney General’s office has pursued cases against fraudulent real estate investors who used deceptive practices to acquire properties below fair value.

This guide breaks down exactly how “we buy houses” companies work, the most common scams and ripoffs to watch for, and a step-by-step process for verifying whether a cash buyer is legitimate before you sign anything.

house sold for cash to a local investor

In this article:

  • How “We Buy Houses” Companies Actually Work
  • Are “We Buy Houses” Offers a Ripoff?
  • 12 Red Flags That Signal a “We Buy Houses” Scam
  • How to Verify a Legitimate Cash Home Buyer
  • Questions to Ask Before Accepting Any Cash Offer
  • What a Fair Cash Offer Actually Looks Like
  • When Selling to a Cash Buyer Makes Sense (and When It Doesn’t)
  • How to Report a Real Estate Scam in New York
  • FAQ: Common Questions About Cash Home Buyers

How “We Buy Houses” Companies Actually Work

“We buy houses” companies are real estate investors who purchase properties directly from homeowners, typically for cash, without requiring the seller to make repairs, stage the home, or pay agent commissions.

The business model is straightforward. These companies buy homes at a discount, renovate them (or hold them as rentals), and then sell or lease the property for a profit. The seller’s benefit is speed and convenience: most legitimate cash buyers can close in 14 to 28 days, compared to the 60 to 90 days it typically takes to sell through a traditional real estate agent on Long Island.

There are several types of cash home buyers operating in New York:

Local real estate investors are individuals or small companies who buy properties in their area, renovate them, and resell them. These buyers tend to have the most flexibility and local market knowledge. We Buy Long Island Homes Fast is an example of a local Long Island investor — founded by Mike Plactere, a licensed New York real estate professional and Certified Public Accountant (CPA) who brings financial transparency to every transaction.

National franchises like HomeVestors (“We Buy Ugly Houses”) and We Buy Houses operate through local franchise owners. Quality varies significantly between individual franchise operators.

iBuyers such as Opendoor and Offerpad use algorithms to make instant offers online. Their offers tend to be closer to market value, but they charge service fees of 5% to 6% and are selective about which properties they’ll buy.

Cash buyer marketplaces aggregate offers from multiple investors, letting sellers compare. Examples include Houzeo and HomeLight’s cash offer platform.

Understanding which type of buyer you’re dealing with is the first step in protecting yourself from potential scams.

Are “We Buy Houses” Offers a Ripoff?

Here’s the honest answer: “we buy houses” companies are not inherently a ripoff, but their offers will be lower than what you’d get selling through a real estate agent on the open market. On average, cash home buyers offer 70% to 85% of a home’s fair market value. That discount reflects the risk the investor takes on (unseen repairs, market changes, holding costs), the cost of renovations, and the convenience they provide to the seller. Here’s a realistic breakdown of how the math works on a $400,000 Long Island home:
Traditional Sale Cash Buyer Sale
Sale Price $400,000 $320,000 (80% of value)
Agent Commissions (5-6%) -$22,000 $0
Repairs & Staging -$15,000 $0
Closing Costs -$8,000 -$2,000 (buyer often pays)
Holding Costs (3-4 months) -$8,000 $0
Net Proceeds $347,000 $318,000
Time to Close 90-120 days 14-28 days
The gap between options is often smaller than people expect once you account for commissions, repairs, and carrying costs. For sellers who need speed, are facing foreclosure, dealing with a tenant-occupied property, or have a home that needs significant work, the math frequently favors a cash sale.

Are “We Buy Houses” Companies Legitimate and Ethical?

Most “we buy houses” companies are legitimate, real businesses that buy homes for cash and close on them. A smaller number are wholesalers or bad actors who use the same signs and the same language, which is why sellers ask this question so often. The difference is not the marketing. It is whether the company is the actual buyer, and whether it behaves honestly once the money is on the table.

A legitimate, ethical cash buyer:

  • Is the buyer, not a middleman. It uses its own funds and closes itself. It does not lock up your house and shop the contract to someone else.
  • Can show proof of funds on request.
  • Has a verifiable track record: real reviews with specific detail, a real local office, and public records of past purchases.
  • Puts the real number in writing and closes on that number, instead of quoting a high number and renegotiating later.
  • Tells you the truth, including when listing with an agent would net you more.

For a step-by-step way to check any buyer, see how to verify a legitimate cash home buyer further down this page.

As a worked example: We Buy Long Island Homes Fast is a direct buyer, not a wholesaler. Mike Plactere is a licensed New York real estate agent and a licensed CPA, so he answers to professional standards most investors do not. Since 2019 we have bought more than 300 homes on Long Island, over $130 million in property. We hold a Better Business Bureau A+ rating and 42 five-star Google reviews, we pay all closing costs, and proof of funds is available on request. That is what “legitimate” looks like in practice.

What's Your Home Really Worth to a Cash Buyer?

Use our free calculator to see how a cash offer compares to a traditional sale.

$
$25,000
$0$150,000
VS

Traditional Sale

Sale Price
Agent Commissions (5.5%)
Repairs & Stagingincl. typical 25% homeowner overage
Closing Costs (2%)
Holding Costs (3 mo)
Net Proceeds
Timeline 90–120 days

Cash Offer

Offer Range
Agent Commissions $0
Repair Costs $0
Closing Costs ~$0
Holding Costs $0
Net Proceeds
Timeline 7–21 days

Professional cash buyers get better pricing on repairs through established contractor relationships and volume purchasing — typically 20–30% less than retail. The traditional sale column includes a 25% overage buffer because homeowner-managed renovations almost always exceed the original estimate.

Offer = (After Repair Value × 73–88%) – Pro Repair Costs

These real-world cost differences are why cash offers are closer to traditional sale proceeds than most people expect. The multiplier varies based on property condition and local market factors.

Want to see your actual offer? Mike Plactere, licensed CPA and real estate professional, will walk you through the numbers personally.

Get Your Free Cash Offer → 📞 Call (631) 825-8747

This calculator provides estimates for educational purposes. Actual cash offers depend on property inspection, local market conditions, and title status. Contact us for a personalized offer.

Why Do Cash for Houses Companies Offer Less Than Market Value?

You might wonder why cash-for-houses companies tend to present offers noticeably lower than what you’d expect on the open market. The answer comes down to their business model and the risks they assume.

These companies specialize in buying properties quickly—often stepping in when a homeowner needs a fast sale due to foreclosure, inheritance, divorce, or extensive repairs. To make the process hassle-free for sellers, they purchase homes “as-is,” absorbing the costs and headaches of upgrades, repairs, and sometimes even legal title issues.

But these perks come with tradeoffs:

  • Lower Offers: To account for repairs, potential holding costs, and their own margin, cash buyers typically make offers below current market value. Their goal is to renovate and resell (or rent) the house at a profit.
  • Risk Factor: Since they’re taking on the responsibility of unseen damage or problems, their offers reflect these unknowns. Essentially, they’re building in a financial cushion just in case the home needs major work.
  • Convenience Premium: Sellers get the benefit of a speedy closing and zero repair obligations, but the price offered reflects the value of convenience.

It’s not a scam if you understand the tradeoff—time and simplicity versus top dollar. For some homeowners, the reduced price is worth bypassing months of showings, negotiations, and open houses. For others, the best value is found on the open market, even if it takes longer.

12 Red Flags That Signal a “We Buy Houses” Scam

Not every “we buy houses” company is operating in good faith. Here are the most common warning signs, based on complaints filed with the Better Business Bureau, the Federal Trade Commission, and the New York Attorney General’s office:

1. They pressure you to sign immediately

Legitimate cash buyers give you time to think, consult an attorney, and compare offers. If someone is pushing you to “sign today or the offer expires,” walk away. Reputable investors know that rushed decisions lead to regret and bad reviews.

2. They won’t provide proof of funds

Any serious cash buyer should be able to show a recent bank statement or a letter from their financial institution confirming they have the funds to close. If they dodge this request, they either don’t have the money or are planning to wholesale your contract to another buyer (often at your expense).

3. The offer seems too good to be true

If a cash buyer offers you more than market value, something is wrong. They may plan to renegotiate after you’ve taken the house off the market, or the contract may contain hidden contingencies that let them back out.

4. They ask for upfront fees

You should never pay a cash buyer to buy your house. No application fees, no “processing fees,” no deposits from the seller. In a legitimate transaction, the buyer puts down earnest money, not the seller.

5. They have no online presence

Search for the company name plus “reviews.” A legitimate operation will have a Google Business Profile, reviews on Google and the BBB, a professional website with a physical address, and verifiable contact information. If they’re invisible online, that’s a problem.

6. They won’t provide references

Experienced cash buyers should be able to connect you with past sellers, a title company they work with, and a real estate attorney they use for closings. Refusal to provide references is a major red flag.

7. The contract has vague or unusual clauses

Watch for overly broad cancellation clauses (“buyer may cancel for any reason”), extended closing timelines (legitimate cash buyers close in weeks, not months), or clauses that allow the buyer to “assign” or resell the contract. Have a New York real estate attorney review any contract before you sign.

8. They discourage you from getting legal advice

Any buyer who discourages you from hiring an attorney is not acting in your interest. In New York, attorneys are typically involved in every real estate transaction. A buyer who tries to skip this step is a red flag.

9. They don’t visit your property

Some scam operators make offers based solely on online data without ever seeing the property. While initial offers can be based on comparable sales, a legitimate buyer will always want to inspect the property before making a final offer.

10. They use a generic email address

Serious real estate companies operate from company email domains, not Gmail or Yahoo addresses. While this alone isn’t definitive, combined with other red flags it suggests the “company” may be one person with no real business infrastructure.

11. Their offer price changes dramatically after the initial offer

Some unscrupulous buyers make a high initial offer to get you to commit, then significantly reduce it after inspection or just before closing when you’ve already made plans based on the original number. This “bait and switch” tactic is one of the most common complaints.

12. They try to bypass the title company or closing attorney

The closing should always go through a licensed title company or real estate attorney. Funds should be wired to an escrow account, not directly to the buyer. Anyone trying to handle the closing informally or outside normal channels is a serious scam risk.

How to Verify a Legitimate Cash Home Buyer

Before accepting any cash offer, run through this verification checklist:

Check the Better Business Bureau

The BBB maintains ratings and complaint histories for businesses. Look for an A or A+ rating and read through any complaints to understand the nature of past issues. An accredited business with a strong rating has met the BBB’s standards for trust.

Read Google Reviews (Carefully)

Google Reviews on a company’s Google Business Profile are one of the most reliable indicators of a company’s reputation. Look for:

  • Volume: A company with 20+ reviews is more trustworthy than one with 2-3.
  • Recency: Reviews from the past 6-12 months indicate the business is active.
  • Specificity: Real reviews mention specific details (the person they worked with, the timeline, the location). Generic five-star reviews with no detail may be fabricated.
  • Responses: Companies that respond to reviews, including negative ones, demonstrate accountability.

Verify Their Real Estate License

In New York, you can verify a real estate license through the New York Department of State’s license search. While not all cash buyers are required to hold a real estate license (investors buying for their own portfolio typically are not), many reputable companies employ licensed agents as part of their team. For example, Mike Plactere of We Buy Long Island Homes Fast holds an active New York real estate license and is also a licensed CPA — credentials you can verify independently through the state’s public databases.

Confirm a Physical Business Address

Search the company’s address on Google Maps. Is it a real office, a residential address, or a virtual office? While some legitimate investors work from home offices, a verifiable business location adds credibility.

Ask for Proof of Past Closings

A legitimate cash buyer should be able to provide:

  • References from past sellers
  • The name and contact information of a title company they regularly work with
  • Examples of past transactions (you can verify these through public records)

Check for Lawsuits and Complaints

Search the company name on the New York State Unified Court System to check for any pending or past lawsuits. Also check the NY Attorney General’s complaint database for any filed complaints.

Questions to Ask Before Accepting Any Cash Offer

Before you commit to any cash buyer, ask these questions and pay close attention to how they respond:

“How did you arrive at your offer price?” A reputable buyer will walk you through their analysis: comparable sales in your area, estimated repair costs, their target profit margin, and how those factors combine to produce their offer. Transparency here is a strong trust signal. You can learn more about how fair cash offers are calculated.

“What happens between now and closing?” Understand the full timeline: when do they inspect the property, when do they finalize the offer, when does the title search happen, and when do you get your money? A legitimate process has clear milestones.

“Are there any fees, commissions, or costs I’ll be responsible for?” Reputable cash buyers cover all closing costs and charge no commissions. Get this confirmed in writing. Some less scrupulous operators bury fees in the contract that effectively reduce your net proceeds.

“Can you provide proof of funds?” This should be a bank statement or letter from a financial institution, dated within the last 30 days. No exceptions.

“What is your earnest money deposit?” A standard earnest money deposit for a cash transaction is 1% to 3% of the purchase price. This money goes to escrow and demonstrates the buyer’s commitment. If they refuse to put down earnest money, they’re not a serious buyer.

“Who handles the closing?” The answer should be a licensed title company or real estate attorney. Ask for the name and contact information so you can verify independently.

“What if the deal falls through?” Understand what happens to your earnest money and what conditions allow either party to exit the contract. A fair contract protects both sides.

we buy houses scams vs verified we buy houses reviews

What a Fair Cash Offer Actually Looks Like

Understanding how cash buyers calculate their offers helps you recognize when an offer is fair versus when you’re being lowballed.

Most legitimate investors use a formula based on the After Repair Value (ARV) of the home:

Offer = (ARV x 70-80%) – Estimated Repair Costs

For example, if your Long Island home would sell for $500,000 after renovations and needs $50,000 in repairs:

  • Conservative offer (70% ARV): ($500,000 x 0.70) – $50,000 = $300,000
  • Competitive offer (80% ARV): ($500,000 x 0.80) – $50,000 = $350,000

If you receive an offer significantly below the 70% threshold without clear justification (major structural issues, environmental problems, extreme market conditions), it may not be a fair deal.

To determine your home’s approximate value, you can check Zillow’s Zestimate, Realtor.com’s home value estimator, or request a professional appraisal.

For Long Island homeowners, our team at We Buy Long Island Homes Fast provides transparent offer breakdowns showing exactly how we arrive at our numbers, so you can see the math for yourself. As a licensed CPA, our founder Mike Plactere walks every seller through the financials line by line — no hidden fees, no surprises at closing.

When Selling to a Cash Buyer Makes Sense (and When It Doesn’t)

A cash sale is often the right choice when:

  • Your home needs significant repairs and you don’t have the resources to make them. Selling as-is to a cash buyer eliminates repair costs entirely.
  • You’re facing foreclosure and need to close before the bank takes action. A cash sale can often stop foreclosure proceedings within weeks.
  • You’ve inherited a property you don’t want to manage, especially if it’s out of state or needs work. Selling an inherited house for cash avoids months of probate delays.
  • You’re going through a divorce and need to liquidate shared property quickly.
  • The property has tenants and selling through traditional channels would require navigating tenant-occupied sale complications.
  • You need to relocate quickly for a job, medical reasons, or a move to assisted living.

A traditional sale is usually better when:

  • Your home is in good condition and move-in ready
  • You’re in a strong seller’s market with high demand
  • You have 3-6 months and no urgency to close
  • Maximizing your sale price is the top priority
  • You have the financial flexibility to cover repairs, staging, and carrying costs while the home is listed

Neither option is universally better. The right choice depends entirely on your specific situation, timeline, and financial needs.

How to Report a Real Estate Scam in New York

If you believe you’ve been targeted by a fraudulent “we buy houses” company in New York, take these steps:

  1. File a complaint with the New York Attorney General at ag.ny.gov/consumer-frauds/filing-consumer-complaint
  2. Report to the FTC at reportfraud.ftc.gov
  3. File with the Better Business Bureau at bbb.org/file-a-complaint
  4. Contact your local District Attorney’s office (for Nassau or Suffolk County)
  5. Report to the New York Department of State if the company claims to hold a real estate license: dos.ny.gov

Document everything: save all communications (texts, emails, voicemails), keep copies of any contracts or agreements, and note dates, times, and names of people you spoke with.

FAQ: Common Questions About Cash Home Buyers

Are “we buy houses” companies legitimate?

Many “we buy houses” companies are legitimate businesses run by real estate investors who provide a valuable service to homeowners who need to sell quickly. However, like any industry, there are bad actors. The key is verifying the company through reviews, licensing checks, proof of funds, and references before committing to a sale. Look for companies with established Google Reviews, a BBB profile, and a physical business address.

How much do “we buy houses” companies pay?

Most cash home buyers offer between 70% and 85% of a home’s fair market value, depending on the property’s condition, location, and needed repairs. The tradeoff is speed and convenience: no commissions (saving 5-6%), no repair costs, and a closing timeline of 1-3 weeks instead of 3-4 months.

Is “We Buy Ugly Houses” (HomeVestors) a scam?

HomeVestors is a legitimate national franchise, not a scam. However, because they operate through independent franchise owners, the experience can vary significantly depending on the individual operator in your area. Always research the specific local franchise you’re dealing with, not just the national brand.

What is the #1 red flag of a “we buy houses” scam?

The single biggest red flag is being asked to pay money upfront. In a legitimate cash home sale, the seller never pays the buyer. If anyone asks you for a fee, deposit, or payment before closing, it’s almost certainly a scam.

Should I get multiple cash offers?

Absolutely. Getting 2-3 cash offers gives you leverage and a clear picture of what your home is actually worth to investors. It also helps you identify outlier offers, both suspiciously high (potential bait-and-switch) and unreasonably low (lowball tactics). For Long Island homeowners, you can request a no-obligation cash offer to use as a comparison point.

Do I need a lawyer to sell my house for cash in New York?

Yes, and this is non-negotiable. New York requires an attorney to be involved in real estate transactions. Any cash buyer who tries to close without legal representation is either uninformed or acting against your interests. Your attorney will review the contract, ensure clear title, and protect your interests at closing.

How fast can a cash buyer close on my house?

Most legitimate cash buyers can close in 14 to 28 days once a purchase agreement is signed. Some can close even faster if there are no title issues. Traditional sales through a real estate agent typically take 60 to 120 days on Long Island.

Can I sell my house for cash if I still have a mortgage?

Yes. The mortgage balance is paid off from the sale proceeds at closing, just like in a traditional sale. The title company handles the payoff directly with your lender. You receive the difference between the sale price and your remaining mortgage balance.

happy homeowners after selling their house for cash

This guide was written by Mike Plactere, founder of We Buy Long Island Homes Fast, a locally owned cash home buying company serving Nassau County, Suffolk County, and the rest of Long Island. Mike is a licensed New York real estate agent and a licensed CPA, a level of financial and regulatory accountability that is rare in this business.

We are a direct buyer, not a wholesaler. We buy your house with our own cash, we close it ourselves, and we renovate and resell it. We do not tie your house up and shop the contract to someone else. Proof of funds is available on request.

Since 2019 we have bought more than 300 homes on Long Island, over $130 million in property. We hold an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau and 42 five-star Google reviews from Long Island sellers. We pay all closing costs, charge no commissions, and give you a cash offer within 24 hours.

We will also tell you the truth about timing. Some companies advertise a 7-day close. In New York, with attorney review and title work, that is rarely realistic. We give you a cash offer within 24 hours and close on your timeline, honestly.

If you have questions about selling your home for cash, or you want a no-obligation cash offer to see where you stand, get your free cash offer here or call us at (631) 825-8747.

Sell Your House Now - Get Fair Cash Offer

Please submit your property information below now to receive a fair all cash offer.

homeowner getting a cash offer from we buy long island homes fast
   By submitting this form and signing up for texts, you consent to receive marketing text messages from We Buy Long Island Homes Fast at the number provided, including messages sent by autodialer. Consent is not a condition of purchase. Msg & data rates may apply. Unsubscribe at any time by replying STOP or clicking the unsubscribe link (where available).

Trusted By Long Island Home Sellers