If you’ve seen those “we buy houses for cash” signs stapled to telephone poles or received an unsolicited postcard offering to buy your home, your first thought was probably: is this a scam?
It’s a fair question. The “we buy houses” industry includes thousands of legitimate local investors alongside a smaller but vocal group of bad actors who prey on homeowners in vulnerable situations. In New York alone, the Attorney General’s office has pursued cases against fraudulent real estate investors who used deceptive practices to acquire properties below fair value.
This guide breaks down exactly how “we buy houses” companies work, the most common scams and ripoffs to watch for, and a step-by-step process for verifying whether a cash buyer is legitimate before you sign anything.
In this article:
“We buy houses” companies are real estate investors who purchase properties directly from homeowners, typically for cash, without requiring the seller to make repairs, stage the home, or pay agent commissions.
The business model is straightforward. These companies buy homes at a discount, renovate them (or hold them as rentals), and then sell or lease the property for a profit. The seller’s benefit is speed and convenience: most legitimate cash buyers can close in 7 to 21 days, compared to the 60 to 90 days it typically takes to sell through a traditional real estate agent on Long Island.
There are several types of cash home buyers operating in New York:
Local real estate investors are individuals or small companies who buy properties in their area, renovate them, and resell them. These buyers tend to have the most flexibility and local market knowledge. We Buy Long Island Homes Fast is an example of a local Long Island investor — founded by Mike Plactere, a licensed New York real estate professional and Certified Public Accountant (CPA) who brings financial transparency to every transaction.
National franchises like HomeVestors (“We Buy Ugly Houses”) and We Buy Houses operate through local franchise owners. Quality varies significantly between individual franchise operators.
iBuyers such as Opendoor and Offerpad use algorithms to make instant offers online. Their offers tend to be closer to market value, but they charge service fees of 5% to 6% and are selective about which properties they’ll buy.
Cash buyer marketplaces aggregate offers from multiple investors, letting sellers compare. Examples include Houzeo and HomeLight’s cash offer platform.
Understanding which type of buyer you’re dealing with is the first step in protecting yourself from potential scams.
Here’s the honest answer: “we buy houses” companies are not inherently a ripoff, but their offers will be lower than what you’d get selling through a real estate agent on the open market.
On average, cash home buyers offer 70% to 85% of a home’s fair market value. That discount reflects the risk the investor takes on (unseen repairs, market changes, holding costs), the cost of renovations, and the convenience they provide to the seller.
Here’s a realistic breakdown of how the math works on a $400,000 Long Island home:
Traditional Sale | Cash Buyer Sale | |
Sale Price | $400,000 | $320,000 (80% of value) |
Agent Commissions (5-6%) | -$22,000 | $0 |
Repairs & Staging | -$15,000 | $0 |
Closing Costs | -$8,000 | -$2,000 (buyer often pays) |
Holding Costs (3-4 months) | -$8,000 | $0 |
Net Proceeds | $347,000 | $318,000 |
Time to Close | 90-120 days | 7-21 days |
The gap between options is often smaller than people expect once you account for commissions, repairs, and carrying costs. For sellers who need speed, are facing foreclosure, dealing with a tenant-occupied property, or have a home that needs significant work, the math frequently favors a cash sale.
Use our free calculator to see how a cash offer compares to a traditional sale.
Professional cash buyers get better pricing on repairs through established contractor relationships and volume purchasing — typically 20–30% less than retail. The traditional sale column includes a 25% overage buffer because homeowner-managed renovations almost always exceed the original estimate.
These real-world cost differences are why cash offers are closer to traditional sale proceeds than most people expect. The multiplier varies based on property condition and local market factors.
Want to see your actual offer? Mike Plactere, licensed CPA and real estate professional, will walk you through the numbers personally.
This calculator provides estimates for educational purposes. Actual cash offers depend on property inspection, local market conditions, and title status. Contact us for a personalized offer.
You might wonder why cash-for-houses companies tend to present offers noticeably lower than what you’d expect on the open market. The answer comes down to their business model and the risks they assume.
These companies specialize in buying properties quickly—often stepping in when a homeowner needs a fast sale due to foreclosure, inheritance, divorce, or extensive repairs. To make the process hassle-free for sellers, they purchase homes “as-is,” absorbing the costs and headaches of upgrades, repairs, and sometimes even legal title issues.
But these perks come with tradeoffs:
It’s not a scam if you understand the tradeoff—time and simplicity versus top dollar. For some homeowners, the reduced price is worth bypassing months of showings, negotiations, and open houses. For others, the best value is found on the open market, even if it takes longer.
Not every “we buy houses” company is operating in good faith. Here are the most common warning signs, based on complaints filed with the Better Business Bureau, the Federal Trade Commission, and the New York Attorney General’s office:
Legitimate cash buyers give you time to think, consult an attorney, and compare offers. If someone is pushing you to “sign today or the offer expires,” walk away. Reputable investors know that rushed decisions lead to regret and bad reviews.
Any serious cash buyer should be able to show a recent bank statement or a letter from their financial institution confirming they have the funds to close. If they dodge this request, they either don’t have the money or are planning to wholesale your contract to another buyer (often at your expense).
If a cash buyer offers you more than market value, something is wrong. They may plan to renegotiate after you’ve taken the house off the market, or the contract may contain hidden contingencies that let them back out.
You should never pay a cash buyer to buy your house. No application fees, no “processing fees,” no deposits from the seller. In a legitimate transaction, the buyer puts down earnest money, not the seller.
Search for the company name plus “reviews.” A legitimate operation will have a Google Business Profile, reviews on Google and the BBB, a professional website with a physical address, and verifiable contact information. If they’re invisible online, that’s a problem.
Experienced cash buyers should be able to connect you with past sellers, a title company they work with, and a real estate attorney they use for closings. Refusal to provide references is a major red flag.
Watch for overly broad cancellation clauses (“buyer may cancel for any reason”), extended closing timelines (legitimate cash buyers close in weeks, not months), or clauses that allow the buyer to “assign” or resell the contract. Have a New York real estate attorney review any contract before you sign.
Any buyer who discourages you from hiring an attorney is not acting in your interest. In New York, attorneys are typically involved in every real estate transaction. A buyer who tries to skip this step is a red flag.
Some scam operators make offers based solely on online data without ever seeing the property. While initial offers can be based on comparable sales, a legitimate buyer will always want to inspect the property before making a final offer.
Serious real estate companies operate from company email domains, not Gmail or Yahoo addresses. While this alone isn’t definitive, combined with other red flags it suggests the “company” may be one person with no real business infrastructure.
Some unscrupulous buyers make a high initial offer to get you to commit, then significantly reduce it after inspection or just before closing when you’ve already made plans based on the original number. This “bait and switch” tactic is one of the most common complaints.
The closing should always go through a licensed title company or real estate attorney. Funds should be wired to an escrow account, not directly to the buyer. Anyone trying to handle the closing informally or outside normal channels is a serious scam risk.
Before accepting any cash offer, run through this verification checklist:
The BBB maintains ratings and complaint histories for businesses. Look for an A or A+ rating and read through any complaints to understand the nature of past issues. An accredited business with a strong rating has met the BBB’s standards for trust.
Google Reviews on a company’s Google Business Profile are one of the most reliable indicators of a company’s reputation. Look for:
In New York, you can verify a real estate license through the New York Department of State’s license search. While not all cash buyers are required to hold a real estate license (investors buying for their own portfolio typically are not), many reputable companies employ licensed agents as part of their team. For example, Mike Plactere of We Buy Long Island Homes Fast holds an active New York real estate license and is also a licensed CPA — credentials you can verify independently through the state’s public databases.
Search the company’s address on Google Maps. Is it a real office, a residential address, or a virtual office? While some legitimate investors work from home offices, a verifiable business location adds credibility.
A legitimate cash buyer should be able to provide:
Search the company name on the New York State Unified Court System to check for any pending or past lawsuits. Also check the NY Attorney General’s complaint database for any filed complaints.
Before you commit to any cash buyer, ask these questions and pay close attention to how they respond:
“How did you arrive at your offer price?” A reputable buyer will walk you through their analysis: comparable sales in your area, estimated repair costs, their target profit margin, and how those factors combine to produce their offer. Transparency here is a strong trust signal. You can learn more about how fair cash offers are calculated.
“What happens between now and closing?” Understand the full timeline: when do they inspect the property, when do they finalize the offer, when does the title search happen, and when do you get your money? A legitimate process has clear milestones.
“Are there any fees, commissions, or costs I’ll be responsible for?” Reputable cash buyers cover all closing costs and charge no commissions. Get this confirmed in writing. Some less scrupulous operators bury fees in the contract that effectively reduce your net proceeds.
“Can you provide proof of funds?” This should be a bank statement or letter from a financial institution, dated within the last 30 days. No exceptions.
“What is your earnest money deposit?” A standard earnest money deposit for a cash transaction is 1% to 3% of the purchase price. This money goes to escrow and demonstrates the buyer’s commitment. If they refuse to put down earnest money, they’re not a serious buyer.
“Who handles the closing?” The answer should be a licensed title company or real estate attorney. Ask for the name and contact information so you can verify independently.
“What if the deal falls through?” Understand what happens to your earnest money and what conditions allow either party to exit the contract. A fair contract protects both sides.
Understanding how cash buyers calculate their offers helps you recognize when an offer is fair versus when you’re being lowballed.
Most legitimate investors use a formula based on the After Repair Value (ARV) of the home:
Offer = (ARV x 70-80%) – Estimated Repair Costs
For example, if your Long Island home would sell for $500,000 after renovations and needs $50,000 in repairs:
If you receive an offer significantly below the 70% threshold without clear justification (major structural issues, environmental problems, extreme market conditions), it may not be a fair deal.
To determine your home’s approximate value, you can check Zillow’s Zestimate, Realtor.com’s home value estimator, or request a professional appraisal.
For Long Island homeowners, our team at We Buy Long Island Homes Fast provides transparent offer breakdowns showing exactly how we arrive at our numbers, so you can see the math for yourself. As a licensed CPA, our founder Mike Plactere walks every seller through the financials line by line — no hidden fees, no surprises at closing.
Neither option is universally better. The right choice depends entirely on your specific situation, timeline, and financial needs.
If you believe you’ve been targeted by a fraudulent “we buy houses” company in New York, take these steps:
Document everything: save all communications (texts, emails, voicemails), keep copies of any contracts or agreements, and note dates, times, and names of people you spoke with.
Many “we buy houses” companies are legitimate businesses run by real estate investors who provide a valuable service to homeowners who need to sell quickly. However, like any industry, there are bad actors. The key is verifying the company through reviews, licensing checks, proof of funds, and references before committing to a sale. Look for companies with established Google Reviews, a BBB profile, and a physical business address.
Most cash home buyers offer between 70% and 85% of a home’s fair market value, depending on the property’s condition, location, and needed repairs. The tradeoff is speed and convenience: no commissions (saving 5-6%), no repair costs, and a closing timeline of 1-3 weeks instead of 3-4 months.
HomeVestors is a legitimate national franchise, not a scam. However, because they operate through independent franchise owners, the experience can vary significantly depending on the individual operator in your area. Always research the specific local franchise you’re dealing with, not just the national brand.
The single biggest red flag is being asked to pay money upfront. In a legitimate cash home sale, the seller never pays the buyer. If anyone asks you for a fee, deposit, or payment before closing, it’s almost certainly a scam.
Absolutely. Getting 2-3 cash offers gives you leverage and a clear picture of what your home is actually worth to investors. It also helps you identify outlier offers, both suspiciously high (potential bait-and-switch) and unreasonably low (lowball tactics). For Long Island homeowners, you can request a no-obligation cash offer to use as a comparison point.
Yes, and this is non-negotiable. New York requires an attorney to be involved in real estate transactions. Any cash buyer who tries to close without legal representation is either uninformed or acting against your interests. Your attorney will review the contract, ensure clear title, and protect your interests at closing.
Most legitimate cash buyers can close in 7 to 21 days once a purchase agreement is signed. Some can close even faster if there are no title issues. Traditional sales through a real estate agent typically take 60 to 120 days on Long Island.
Yes. The mortgage balance is paid off from the sale proceeds at closing, just like in a traditional sale. The title company handles the payoff directly with your lender. You receive the difference between the sale price and your remaining mortgage balance.
This guide was written by Mike Plactere, founder of We Buy Long Island Homes Fast — a locally owned cash home buying company serving Nassau County, Suffolk County, and the greater Long Island area. Mike is a licensed New York real estate professional and a Certified Public Accountant (CPA), bringing a level of financial expertise and regulatory accountability that is rare in the cash home buying industry. Our company maintains an A+ BBB rating and consistently earns 5-star reviews from Long Island homeowners.
We believe that transparency makes the entire industry better. As a CPA, Mike holds himself to a professional code of ethics that goes beyond what’s required of most real estate investors. If you have questions about selling your home for cash, or you’d like a no-obligation offer to see where you stand, get your free cash offer here or call us directly at (631) 825-8747.
Please submit your property information below now to receive a fair all cash offer.
Trusted By Long Island Home Sellers
